Is Average Bad? External Validation and Comparing Yourself to Others

Guest: Barry Michels Do ever you feel bad when you compare yourself to others? Would you get pissed if someone called you “average”? And what’s more important to you: being the best you can be or being better than someone else? The Tools and Coming Alive co-author Barry Michels is back to discuss the trap of external validation. We’re going to talk about how trying to be better than others is an un-winnable game and how we can learn how to play our own game instead. In this interview:
  • Why seeking external validation through money, sex, and attention is an un-winnable game
  • The difference between creating and getting
  • What if you were to give up hope that you’ll ever get the external reward you want?
  • The huge difference between being the best you can be vs being the best in the world (or industry, community, etc.)
  • Why being average is so scary for so many
  • How to tell if you’re being a “black hole” or a “sun”
  • How to tell if you’re the icky sales guy (that creeps everyone out) or someone who inspires others
Click here for Barry Michels book Coming Alive: 4 Tools to Defeat Your Inner Enemy, Ignite Creative Expression & Unleash Your Soul’s Potential.

About Barry Michels

https://thetoolsbook.com Barry Michels powered through his undergraduate studies at Harvard, went to law school at the University of California at Berkeley, and spent three years at a white-shoe law firm before disillusionment got the better of him. After a soul-searching time in Europe where he played guitar on street corners, he had a powerful spiritual experience and realized he wanted to be a therapist. He returned home and got an MSW from the University of Southern California and began his psychotherapy practice in 1986. A few years later, still searching for a psychotherapeutic technique that would bring his patients true freedom, he attended a seminar held by Phil. Struck by Phil’s commitment to human potential and his unorthodox approach, he began to study with Phil and use The Tools with his patients. Click here for Barry Michels book Coming Alive: 4 Tools to Defeat Your Inner Enemy, Ignite Creative Expression & Unleash Your Soul’s Potential.

Transcript

The trap of needing to be significant

Barry: Thanks so much for having me, Tripp.

Tripp: I'm excited to have you back. We've talked about certain topics on the show before, but there's this other one that comes up, and it shows up a lot in my own life. It shows up in others that I'm working with. It's this trap, this need to be significant. You work and live in LA, you work with celebrities and powerful people, so I imagine this whole thing about being exceptional and significant comes up a lot there. To be specific, here's what I'm referring to. We can be having a great day and then we find some way to compare ourselves to somebody else who appears to be doing better than us, and all of a sudden our mood is shot to hell. It's the successful executive that so many appreciate and look up to, and he seemingly has it all. But if you get to know him inside, he's really pissed off that he's not one of the guys who became billionaires. It's the guy who broke up with a girl, finds out she's traded up and now she's got a richer, better-looking guy, and now he's devastated. I even read about a woman with anorexia who was scared to get treatment because she wondered who she would be without her disease. For her, having anorexia made her special. It made her unique. And it seems to be getting more intense as social media posts are often determined by what's going to make us look special or better than others.

When I'm coaching people, their resistance or their deep fear to change usually isn't about physical survival. A lot of times they're going to be fine in that way. The insidious thing we bump into is ego survival. They're up against, am I going to lose my status? What if others see me as less than whatever? They stay in lousy jobs and relationships and situations just because they're afraid to jeopardize their self-image. They'll trade their peace of mind in order to protect how they're perceived by others. They'll self-sabotage if they think they're going to go backwards in some way related to their self-image or status. And when we dig a bit further, underneath is this deep-seated fear of being average or just another face in the crowd. So that's why I wanted to have you on the show. I'm imagining you work with folks whose whole existence is built around this need to be exceptional and significant. I want to learn more about what you see, what's going on, and how we can help the folks out there get unhooked from what I think is an unwinnable game. Does that sound good?

Barry: That sounds great.

Tripp: Okay. So how does this show up in your office? Give us a sense of what you see from time to time, maybe in your own life or with the people that you're talking to.

Reframing exceptionalism: an internal metric

Barry: Well, before I do that, let me reframe the issue a little bit, because there's a subtle distinction we need to draw. I believe in trying to become an exceptional person. I believe in trying to fulfill your own potential. To me, the real issue arises when we measure your success at that, and what is the metric that we use? If we're using an external metric, whether it's the amount of money you make or the recognition you get or the number of hits you get on social media or the beauty of your girlfriend or boyfriend or whatever it is, then to be honest, you're kind of screwed, because there's always going to be somebody who has more, and there's always going to be somebody who has less. You're never truly going to be exceptional in that sense. And by the way, even if you do have more money than God and you get to the top of the heap, you always have to be worried there's somebody coming up behind you who will topple your position.

So I think the real solution, and what I teach my patients, is that the feeling of exceptionalism, the feeling of "I'm doing something of value," has to come from inside. In other words, it has to come from that feeling of "I am growing, I am giving out and creating the best that I can possibly create." If the feeling of "I'm putting out my best every moment of every day" is a palpable experience, then you're going to feel good about yourself regardless of the results that you get, and regardless of the roller coaster of "I'm getting attention today and I'm not getting attention tomorrow."

A typical example would be an actor who does a movie, and the movie gets a lot of play and maybe starts to win some awards. The actor is getting a lot of publicity and they're getting mentioned for even better parts, maybe even the movie wins an Oscar. And then the day after the Oscar, the attention disappears, and they aren't necessarily able to leverage it into anything great. The more they have been seduced into measuring their self-worth by what they're receiving, the more insecure they actually become in the long run, because the world gives and then it takes away. There's no guarantee that you're ever going to get any constant stream of attention or validation or rewards from the outside world. So am I being clear? The sense of value or exceptionalism has to come from "I am putting out. I am creating. I am fulfilling my potential in the best way that I can," every hour of every day. And if you've got that, it won't matter whether you're being ignored or celebrated or anything else from the outside world.

Tripp: It's this inside-out approach. And like you said, you have to shift what you're using to measure that. I could be doing pretty lousy work, but get a lot of validation for it, and that still won't be satisfying deeply, because I know deep down it's not really the best work that I can give. Is that what you're speaking to?

Barry: You know deep down that it's not the best work you can do, and you also know deep down that attention and results from the outside world are always fickle. You might be getting it today, but who knows, you might not get it tomorrow. Another patient group that I've treated that really goes through this big time is athletes. The average age of retirement for an athlete is like 30 years old. So they get this incredible dose of fame and attention and people just loving them up, and money and everything, when they're very young and very susceptible to becoming addicted to that and defining themselves around it. And then they retire, and nobody gives a shit whether they exist or not. Nobody's paying any attention to them. And usually there's a deep depressive period after that as they have to shift their values around and start to organize themselves around, "All right, what can I now put out for the rest of my life that will give me an intrinsic sense of joy and satisfaction?"

Renunciation: giving up hope of external reward

Tripp: Okay, so we've got to unpack that. If this is happening to me and I'm riding this roller coaster, one day I'm up because I'm getting validation and that stuff's coming to me, and then the next day it's not, and oh no, there goes my mood. I've got to learn to reorient. Is it just detaching from that kind of input or that kind of validation, or do I shun it? How do you help people turn that corner?

Barry: The simplest kind of tool to give people is what Phil and I call a renunciation. A renunciation is a voluntary giving up of something that you think you need but you really don't, and that you can't necessarily guarantee. So the typical renunciation is, "I give up all hope of getting any external reward for what I do in the form of validation, recognition, money, fame, etc. Instead, I'm going to put out my best, and that's where I'm going to get my sense of satisfaction." Now, the irony is that people who can give up on getting external rewards tend to be much more passionate and creative and authentic, because they don't care. They're doing it for themselves. As a therapist, the best sessions are when I can tell the patient a truth that's hard for them to swallow, and I don't worry whether they liked it or not. I'm just speaking the truth. And ironically, most of the time, people really like it, even if it's hard to hear, because no one's ever been that truthful to them before.

Tripp: Right. As a coach, early on I was so worried about getting it right and being a good coach, and I would just beat myself up after sessions because I wasn't getting it right. I would criticize myself from all these perspectives, and I decided I was going to quit. I was just too miserable. And then I said, well, I might as well try to get fired. Not out of being inappropriate, but I'd say the things that I'm scared to say, in service of the client. And suddenly the work got a lot better. I was enjoying it a lot more, but I was also serving much more deeply when I started to play my own game and knew that I was willing to be fired in any session.

Barry: That's fantastic. You didn't think of that as a renunciation, but that was a renunciation. It was basically, "Fire me. I'm going to say the truths that are inside of me. I'm going to value what I put out rather than what I get back." And it's under those circumstances that you actually put out your best, because you're not seeking anything back for it.

Now, just to complete the idea of renunciation, when you're saying to yourself, "I give up all hope of getting an external reward in this moment for what I'm going to do," it shouldn't feel good, because you're giving up something that, let's face it, all of us have grounded our identity in. I want people to like me, or I want money, or whatever it is. So I'm not saying that it feels good in the moment. But if you can ride through those bad feelings, that feeling of loss, like, "Whoa, I'm giving this up and I'm really just going to focus on what I put out," what happens over time is that it frees you. It frees you to be the best that you can be, to develop your own skills, to learn what you have to give to the world rather than constantly seeking what the world can give to you.

Playing your own game

Tripp: I get this image that many of us are trying to play this game of how to get more of whatever, fill in the blank, these external things: money, fame, validation. And we really think that's the winnable game. What you're talking about is that if I'm willing to put that stuff aside, there's a much bigger game, or I keep using the word game, but we get to play our own game, and that's where the real satisfaction is. That's where the real power is, because I'm no longer tied to those things. I'm no longer a slave to them.

Barry: That's exactly right. And the people who have really changed the world of art or music or computers or whatever, if you study their lives, they've labored for a long time, sometimes their entire lives, in complete obscurity, because they loved what they were doing. Van Gogh is a great example. He never sold a painting in his entire life, but thank God he kept painting for the love of painting.

Tripp: And when people come to you for this, are they coming on the front end, like, "Hey, I want to be a great actor and I want to figure this stuff out now before I get hooked in," or are they coming to you after the fact, like, "Oh my gosh, I'm torn up by this game"?

Barry: It's both, really. People come on the front end because they feel like they're not getting enough fame. It's like they come to the therapist to see if he has some trick where they can get more love from the outside world.

Tripp: But they don't get that that's the thing holding them back. They're coming to you thinking they need more.

Barry: Exactly. They leave the first session bewildered, because I have completely blown their mind. Like, whoa, everything I was looking for is the wrong thing. And then sometimes people come at the back end. And look, let's face it, we're not just one or the other. We're all a mixture of both. I think finally in my career I'm at the point where I don't really care. I just want to be the best therapist I can be. I have my own style. I have my own way of helping people, and I know I'm good at it. I know that I can get people unstuck and give to them. And if they don't like me, they can go elsewhere. It's fine with me, absolutely fine.

But there are always times when, I remember, maybe 5 or 10 years ago, a patient of mine dropped out of therapy, and a little while later I found out he was seeing another therapist. And I got a moment of, "Whoa, what's wrong with me?" So it's a constant life work where you have to keep saying, "I give up hope." That's absolutely okay. In fact, maybe that other therapist is better for that guy than I am, and I want him to get help where he can find it. If I'm not the right person, good. I'm glad he left and found someone else.

Tripp: Right. You said something in your language there that I want to touch on, which is "I want to be the best I can be," which is different from this other mindset: "I want to be the best in the world," or the best in the town. That's dependent upon this comparison to others. But "the best I can be" is a different thing. It may just seem like semantics, but it's a hugely powerful shift.

Barry: It's hugely powerful because you're really saying that the locus of value, the center of value, is inside. It's not out there, which is frankly a blessing, because I can always give more. I can always improve what I do in my own eyes, but what's out there, I can't compel it to give to me. Again, Van Gogh was a great artist, but he couldn't compel people to buy his paintings. He just had to keep painting. So you're making a dramatic shift in values where you're saying, "The value is already in me and I just want to put it out there as best I can. I'm not looking for anyone to recognize it as value as I do."

Tripp: Got it.

Barry: And there's real satisfaction in that. It's hard to put into words, but I know you've had moments where you're saying something or putting something out and you feel like, "Whoa, this is intense. This is amazing. I didn't know I could say this." I live for those moments, because I don't really care how they're taken. Usually they're taken really well anyway, because I think the person senses that I'm in a flow. But regardless of the impact or whatever I get back from the outside world, those are the moments where I feel truly free and truly like I'm maximizing my potential.

Competing with yourself, and why comparison runs so deep

Tripp: I think it's great to have a sense of humor about this. I do this workout several times a week. It's really intense, and we wear these heart monitors. You can see a screen on the wall showing how intense you're going, and that's what you shoot for. There just happen to be other people doing the same workout around you, and it's easy to get into this competitive, comparative thing. Some days I'm in there and I'm just rocking it, and I can hear this voice in me like, "Maybe I could be in the Olympics next year. Maybe I'll be the first 45-year-old guy," whatever it is. And then other days somebody's grandmother is just wiping the floor with me, just crushing me, and I'm devastated. But the effort is still the same. I can watch how my ego, my whole mood, can go up and down when I'm looking through the lens of whether somebody's doing better or worse than me.

Barry: Yes, exactly. And I like the way you put it. Essentially, the healthy position is I'm competing with myself. I'm not competing with anyone else. In fact, weirdly enough, I want other people to be really good at what they do. It's okay with me. I just want to focus on myself: am I getting better, am I getting stronger, am I doing the absolute utmost I can do today, right now?

Tripp: This sounds idealistic. I can hear guys nodding like, "Yeah, yeah, yeah, but still there's this competitive thing." It seems like it's on this primitive cellular level. Is this just left over from us trying to figure out who the biggest ape was in the jungle? How do we explain why this is such a powerful thing to us?

Barry: It's just built into human nature to want to stand out and really be known. I think where this really goes deep, and I'm not saying this is conscious for anyone, is that we don't really believe deep down inside that we exist unless we are noticed, seen. And the metrics we use in our society for being noticed are money, fame, hits on social media, that kind of thing. So think of Part X, or the ego, as a part of you that doesn't really believe that it exists or that it is visible, that it has any value, unless it's getting a constant stream of that kind of attention from the outside world. And believe me, I'm not a saint. I'm prey to that. Everybody falls prey to that. The problem is nothing is ever enough.

I see this all the time because I treat fairly famous, wealthy people. And one of the things they constantly come up against is, "My God, I've made more money or I'm more famous than I ever imagined I would be and I still want more. What the fuck is wrong with me?" And thankfully they're healthy enough to recognize that's a disease.

Tripp: Yeah.

Barry: But it's easy, particularly for someone who doesn't have it, to think that those who do have it are free of it, like they've graduated to some other level where they're just happy with what they have. I treated one billionaire who owns this gigantic yacht, I mean, it's the size of the Queen Mary. He goes yacht racing with his friends, and when they sail into a port, they're all comparing the size of their yachts with each other. It's like the old thing of guys comparing the size of their dicks.

Tripp: Yeah.

Barry: So most of them are unhappy, because there's one guy, obviously, who's got the biggest one. And that is the road to ruin. You're never ever happy if you're always competing with someone else.

The fear of being average

Tripp: The thing that I'm pulling away from there is that there seems to be this fear of being average. It's why I think the studies say that most people think they're above average. They've created this self-image that I can't be average, that I don't exist if I'm average, or I don't exist if I'm just blending into the crowd. And when you say I don't exist, that feels like death. That feels like I'm not here. I'm not important. I'm gone. I'm invisible. That was a big piece that just landed for me. Why would it be such a big deal? What's wrong with average?

Barry: I think you said it really well. Underneath, we use words like "average" or "I'm just normal," but what we're really feeling, if you study the feeling that underlies those words, is "I'm afraid that I'm going to disappear into the gray mass of mediocre people who don't stand out and who are just invisible, just part of the crowd." And again, it's okay that we have that fear inside of us. The solution to it, though, is not to try to get recognition from the outside world. It's to recognize yourself. In other words, the solution is, "I see that I exist, I see that I have value, and I am going to bring value to every single step that I take. Everything that I put out to the world, I'm the one who values it." And no one can ever take that away from you, because it's just between you and yourself. Whereas the other type of value, the kind that comes from the outside world, is constantly being taken away from you, no matter how rich or famous you are.

Putting renunciation into practice: the black hole and the sun

Tripp: When we talk about this renunciation, how can we help the listener put that into practice? I imagine this is something he's got to think about daily, especially if he's crafted a life that is oriented toward "How do I get more validation? How do I get more of these hits?" What does a practical process look like for him to start to ease out of that way of being?

Barry: I think of it as almost retraining the way you operate in the world. If I were talking to a patient who has this problem, and almost everyone does, I would say to them: at the very beginning of the day, first thing when you wake up, close your eyes again and say, "I give up all hope of getting anything back from the world. What I want to do is give out the best that I can." Now, I'm making it a general statement. Of course it could be more specific depending on what you do for a living or whether you have a family or not. For someone who's a stay-at-home mom, it might be, "I give up all hope of getting anything back for what I do with my kids today. What I want to do is do my absolute utmost best to give them structure, to give them love, and to bring them up and make them good citizens."

I'm going to have them bookend the day, so at the very beginning of the day and at the very end of the day. And then I'm going to have them look for cues during the day. A cue is simply a moment where your value shifts, usually not because you've intended it to, it just happens, and you start measuring yourself by something outside of you. So you find yourself comparing yourself to another mom on the bench, or to some other employee at your company. That's a cue to use renunciation again. "Whoops, I fucked up. I give up all hope of being any better than anyone else by any external metric. I just want to do the best that I can do. Am I failing myself right now? If I am, great. How can I succeed? How can I push myself even further?"

Tripp: If we've been a performer, if everything has been a performance in order to get something from the outside world, that's going to be a big shift, to come back to what do I stand for, what's really important to me. And I just like this image of, when my head hits the pillow tonight, what's really going to give me the most satisfaction?

Barry: Yes.

Tripp: Other than that dopamine hit that we get from the recognition or the likes or something.

Barry: Yes. And sometimes, by the way, people like using images rather than words. I happen to be a person who would prefer not to have to say, "I give up hope of," et cetera. So what I use is the image of a black hole and a sun, and which do I want to be? A black hole, as you might know, is a sun that has collapsed into itself and has become literally a black hole that draws all of the light around it into itself. That's why it's very difficult to see, and for astronomers to measure, because it's not visible. It's just drawing in all of the light and energy around it. That's what you as a human being become when you need hits on social media, you need validation, you need constant attention, you need money, et cetera.

So when I have a moment where I'm having a hard time, I see myself as a black hole and I turn myself into a radiant sun. The sun is the opposite of a black hole. It just gives out, constantly. Think about it: if the sun were conscious, if it were aware of things, it wouldn't give a shit what it's getting back. It's only getting back its own reflected light anyway. It just gives out, and it gives out forever. And the other thing that's important is that it's abundant. In human terms, it's infinite. It just shines forever and gives out light and warmth. And when you can get in touch with that abundance that's inside of you, even just in a visualization like that, you feel good. You feel better. You feel complete and whole inside.

This is another aspect of this dichotomy. People don't realize it, but when you're looking for something to fill you up from the outside world, what you're really saying about yourself without being conscious of it is, "I'm not enough. I'm incomplete, and this attention or money is what's going to complete me." Now, as we know, if you study the lives of celebrities, no amount of attention will ever complete you. It just doesn't work. So if you can get in touch with the abundance inside of you, which again, I just use the image of the sun for, then you're in the proper position, which is, "I'm already whole. I'm already filled up inside. My job is to give out." And again, that can take a myriad of different forms. It can be "I'm giving out to my kids," or "I'm doing the best possible job I can do," or "I'm creating something new." But you've shifted your relationship to the universe at that point. Instead of sucking in, you're giving out.

How you feel around givers and takers

Tripp: Oh man, there's so much good stuff in there. As you were talking about the wholeness piece, and how it feels good to be in that, it also feels good to be in the company of that. I imagine when I've been around a salesperson and they're talking me up, it's like, oh, here it comes. They want something from me, and it feels creepy. It feels icky. It's not a genuine interaction. This person's doing the things that a nice person would do, but I can feel that there's another motive. They're only interacting with me because they want to get something from me. And that feels bad.

And then I also notice that when I'm around certain people and they tell me about their big dream or their big vision for life, I'm wondering, why am I not inspired by that? It's because it's coming from that black hole place. Like, "Once I do this great thing, then I'll be loved, I'll be great, blah, blah, blah." Instead of "I'm here to give something. I'm here to express something in this lifetime." Those are the people that draw me in and inspire me, and I want to know how I can support them. So as you name that, I want to help the listeners pay attention to where you feel drawn to certain people, where you feel drawn to certain energies or repulsed by them. Chances are there's some kind of play going on between these different types of energies that Barry's talking about.

Barry: That's beautifully said. That's exactly right. When you're getting a weird vibe from somebody, most of the time it's because unconsciously they're looking to you for something that they don't feel that they have inside of themselves. And it's an awful feeling, because even if the words are giving, the energy is taking from you in a weird way.

Tripp: Right.

Barry: And you're touching on something else, which is, who do you want to be? Do you want to be that salesman who's not really giving value to others but trying to take for himself? Or do you want to be the guy who inspires you because he's just giving stuff away? I don't mean literally giving stuff away, but his energy is just so giving that he doesn't feel depleted by it, because he's already so filled up inside. Those are the people who can change the world and who can have the greatest impact on other people, because people admire them.

Tripp: Right, right. Beautiful. I just love this conversation. I appreciate you taking the time to talk today. Barry Michels, check out the books he and Phil Stutz have written, *Coming Alive* and *The Tools*. Visit thetoolsbook.com to learn more. Thank you again, buddy.

Barry: Thanks so much, Tripp.